歐洲運營商 Open RAN進展及規(guī)劃報告（2023年2月）-Open RAN MoUprogress updateon maturity;security andenergy efficiency

1

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

energyefficiency

securityand

OpenRANMoU

onmaturity,

progressupdate

modesishelpingOpenRANatleastmatchtheenergyefficiencyoftraditionalRAN.OpenRANMoUOperatorscollaboratewiththeindustrytoincreasetheenergyefficiencyofalltheOpenRANbuildingblocks,withparticularfocusonradiotransmittersandcloudinfrastructure.Inaddition,theyareproposingageneralframeworkforenergymonitoring,focusingontoolsandmethodologiestomeasurepowerconsumptionatallpossiblelevelsoftheOpenRANsystem.Suchreportingofpowermetricsinrealtime,combinedwiththenativeintelligenceofferedbytheOpenRANarchitecturewillunleashfullyautomatedmanagementofthenetworkenergyefficiency.ThiswilleventuallyallowOpenRANtooutperformthetraditionalRAN.

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

Execuitivesummary

2

Executivesummary

AsthemomentumbehindOpenRANcontinuestogrow,itisnaturalthatrelevantexpertsanddecisionmakerswanttounderstanditsprogressandhowtheOpenRANindustryhasrisentothechallenges,inparticularrelatingtomaturity,securityandenergyefficiency.Overthecourseof2022,OpenRANMoUOperatorsencouragedanopendialogueaboutOpenRANandhavetakenstepstounderstandconcernsandaddressvalidquestions.Thispaperrepresentsaprogressreportthathelpstoshowcasethegainsandsettheagendafor2023.Insummary:

Thetechnologygapbetween

traditionalRANandOpenRANisclosing.ConsiderableOpenRANdeploymentsarealreadyvisibleinmarketssuchastheUKandNorthAmerica,facilitatedbygovernmentsupport.InEurope,smalldeployments(trials)arealreadyinplace,newpilotsareannouncedforthisyearandlargerscaledeploymentsareexpectedfrom2025.Akeyfocusin2023willbearoundmaturityof5Gforurbanareasandminimisingsystemintegrationoverheadsbymaturingcertificationdeliveredthroughindustrycommunities.

Maturity

Security

OpenRANMoUOperatorsare

strengtheningcooperationwithrelevantnationalauthoritiestoshareinformationonsecurity,implementationandmanagementofOpenRANnetworks.ReportssuchastheEUNIS(Network&InformationSystems)Co-operationGroup’sassessmentofOpenRANsecurityhavehelpeddevelopstrongsecuritycontrolsforspecification,development,procurement,systemintegration,testingandoperations.OpenRANMoUOperatorshaverequestedtoformallyincludeOpenRANaspartoftheGSMA(GroupeSpecialeMobile

Association)NESAS(NetworkEquipment

SecurityAssuranceScheme)andtheEU′s5GcertificationschemedefinedbyENISA(EuropeanUnionAgencyforCybersecurity).

Energyefficiency

hardwarecombinedwithsleep

Theavailabilityofenergy-efficient

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

1.Technicalandecosystemmaturityandreadiness

3

maturityandreadiness

1.Technicalandecosystem

Message1

ThetechnologicalgapsbetweentraditionalRANandOpenRANaremeltingaway.Someareassuchasnon-complexmacroRUs(e.g.,single-bandproducts,nonmMIMOandlowpowerproducts)andcloudplatformsarealreadyclosetoenablinglarge-scaledeploymentsinvariousmarkets.Otherareassuchascomplexmacroradios(e.g.,mMIMO,multi-bandproducts,particularbandcombinations,etc.)mayrequiredeploymentcommitmentstoacceleratetheenlargementoftherangeofproductalternativeswhileRIC(RANIntelligentController)platformsandthecorrespondingappecosystemneedfurtherdevelopment.

1

Rationale/explanation

?Althoughperformanceoptimisationsarestillmonitoredanddiscussed(e.g.mMIMOuplinkperformanceinthemobilitycase),someproductsarematuringquicklyandcatchingupwithestablishedvendors’productsindifferentcategories(e.g.virtualisedbasebandplatforms,smallcells,enterprisenetworks).Variousmacronetworkandenterprisedeploymentsallovertheworldareproofpointsofthatmaturingprocess.Otherareasstillneedtoimproveasaresultofalackofdevelopment,standardsmaturityorlarge-scaledeployments.

?Radiounitswithspecificbandcombinationsonlyneededbysomeoperatorsincertaingeographicalareasarestillunderrepresentedinnewvendors’portfolios.WhiletraditionalRANvendorsmaintainalargefamilyofradiovariantsforthevariousglobalregions,newvendorsneedtofocusonproductswithhighvolumeandrevenueexpectations.Thatexcludeshighlyefficientmulti-bandradioswithoperator-specificbandcombinations,andthoseincombinationwithlegacyradioaccesstechnologies(RATs)suchas2G.

?TheRICsareentrypointsforsmallormediumenterprises(SMEs)orestablishedcompaniesfromnon-RANareasandthusdrivevendordiversityintheRANarea.Considerableadvancementshavetakenplacefromtechnicalanduse-caseperspectivesintheareaofnon-realtime(non-RT)andnear-realtime(near-RT)RIC.Nevertheless,openissueslikeconflictmitigationbetweenapplicationsorusecaseswhichrequirebothnon-RTandnear-RTRICremaintobesolved.Moreover,therelevanceofusecasesstillneedstobequantifiedinfielddeployments,particularlyforthenear-RTRIC.

?RelatedtoRICinterfacestandardisation,A1andE2interfacesarecompletewithexampleA1typedefinitionsandE2servicemodels.However,multi-vendorimplementationsbasedonstandardscompliantE2andA1interfaceshavenotyetshownupinthemarket.StandardisationofxAppandrAppAPIsisstillongoing,thusastablereferencestandardforonboardingthird-partyxAppsandrAppsonRICplatformsisstillneeded.

4

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

1.Technicalandecosystemmaturityandreadiness

?Fromastandardisationperspective,theopenfronthaulinterfaceisthefirstthathasbeenadoptedbyETSI(ETSITS103859)andimplementedincommercialproducts(aimingatlargescaledeployments).ThisincludesIOTtestcasesandconformancetestspecificationsdefinedbyO-RANALLIANCE.

?AlotofstandardisationworkisdoneforO-Cloudwithmanyspecificationsfordeploymentscenariosandusecaserequirements.However,standardisationoftheO2interfaceisstillnotfullydeveloped

intermsofAPIdatamodelsanddetailedinformationelements.Thesameappliestotheaccelerationabstractionlayer(AAL)specs.

5

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

1.Technicalandecosystemmaturityandreadiness

Message2

Globaldeploymentsarenowreachingthousandsofsitesbutaremainlyexecutedbynewoperatorsingreenfielddeployments.Brownfielddeploymentslagduetothecaptivesituationoperatorsface(vendorlock-in)withmodernisationcyclesundercurrentcontractsandsomemissingkeyfeatures.InEurope,small-scaledeploymentsarealreadyinplaceandmajordeploymentsareexpectedfrom2025.ConsiderableOpenRANdeploymentsarealreadyvisibleinmarketssuchastheUKandNorthAmerica,facilitatedbygovernmentsupport.Nevertheless,efficientdeploymentsinbrownfieldoperatorenvironmentsrequirethesupportofboth4Gand5GinCloudRAN,whichwouldenabledeploymentsofoff-the-shelfHW,CloudSWandrelatedtoolingforautomationandlifecyclemanagement.

2

Rationale/explanation:

?Large-scaledeploymentsinvolvingOpenRAN

elementsarepresentonlyoutsideEuropecurrently.IncountriessuchastheUSA,IndiaorJapan,theOpenRANorpartialOpenRAN(vRAN)deploymentsareprogressing,e.g.VerizonvRANdeployment(10000sitesdeployedoutof20000by2025),Dish(>100005GOpenRANsites),NTTDocomo(100005GOpenRANsites)whileaninitialOpenRANdeploymentstartedintheUK.Othernon-fullyO-RANcompatiblesolutionsarebeingdeployedinhighvolumesbyRakuteninJapan.

?InEurope,themainfactorsdelayingtheOpenRANadoption(besidestheclosing,butstillexistinggaponmaturity)intier-

1operators’brownfielddeploymentsareexistingcontractualobligationswithregardstotraditionalnetworksolutionsandthechallengingfinancialsituationthatoperatorsandserviceprovidersarecurrentlysufferingfrom.Thelatterfactorhasthepotentialtorestrictoperatorsfromplanningadditionalinvestmentinnetworkrenewal,andsodelayOpenRANadoptionatscale.Newcontracts

forthenextmodernisationcyclewillbethevehicleforthewidescaleintroductionofOpenRANinthesecondhalfofthedecadein

Europe.

?DespiteinitialdelaysinEurope,someoperatorshavemadesomestrongcommitmentstowardsOpenRANdeployments,suchastheonefromVodafonecommittingtohave30%oftheirnetworkinOpenRANby2030,orfromOrangeannouncingprogresswiththeirEuropeannetworkupgrades,onlyfeaturingO-RANcompliantproductsfrom2025.

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

1.Technicalandecosystemmaturityandreadiness

6

Message3

Industrycommunitiesareworkingtogethermorecollaborativelytoensurecomplementaritybetweencertificationframeworks.Still,thesystemintegrationchallengeofOpenRANisnotsolvedandcommunities,togetherwithoperatorsandvendors,needtomakefurtherjointprogressonprocedurestoestablishastronguniversalcertificationsystemexecutedinopenlabs.

3

Rationale/explanation:

?TheultimategoalofOpenRANMoUoperatorsisforcertificationtobecomesufficientlyrobustthatanyoperatorcouldrequestcertificatesasaprerequisitefortakingpartinRFPprocessesshoulditwish,promotinganefficientsupplychain.Therefore,awell-working,scalablecertificationsystemforthecomplianceofinterfaceconformancefunctional/non-functionalfeaturesexecutedbyleadingopenlabsisanecessitytominimisetheaddedsystemintegrationeffortofamulti-vendorOpenRANsolution.Certificationandbadgingsystemsneedtobemaintainedbyorganisationsthatarewellsupportedbybothoperatorsandvendors,andindependentfromsinglecompaniesorauthorities.

?TheO-RANALLIANCEistheundoubtedauthorityonOpenRANinterfacestandardsintermsoftheirspecificationandcertification.Avalidationframeworkaroundcomplianceofinterfaceconformanceandinteroperabilityhasbeenputinplacebythetestandintegrationtaskforce(TIFG)whileworkgroups(particularlyworkgroups4and5)publishedinitialtestspecificationstoenableearlycertificationprocessesinopentestandintegrationcentres(OTICs).O-RANALLIANCEisanopenorganisation,coordinatinghealthycooperationamongvendorsandoperators,withthemajorityofmajorvendorsandsupplierssignedupasO-RANALLIANCEmembersandtherestoftheindustryencouragedtojoin.

?TheOpenRANgroupoftheTelecomInfraProject(TIP)isdestinedtobecometheauthorityonproductandsystemfunctional/non-functionalfeaturescertification.WhileacertificationsystemframeworkhasbeenputinplaceandisheavilysupportedbyOpenRANMoUOperators,openissuesexistintheareasoflifecyclemanagementaswellasscalability,andtheseneedtobesortedoutjointly.Furthermore,operatorsandvendorsneedtotakeamoreactiveroleinsupportingTIPindevelopingandimplementingrelevantvalidationplanstoenablecertificationpriortoRFPshortlisting.VariousmajorvendorsstillstayawayfrombecomingTIPmembers.ReasonsmayberootedinamorerestrictiveIPR(intellectualpropertyrights)policyorthemorecentralisedapproachtocertification.ThesehesitationsshouldbeovercometoenableworldwideacceptanceofTIPcertificationandbadging.

?Bothorganisationsshouldbecomplementaryintheirscope.Amajorsteptowardsthatwasmadein2022,whenTIPandO-RANALLIANCEannouncedanagreementonmutualacceptanceofcertificatesandbadgeswithintheowncertificationactivities.However,detailedworkonspecificareassuchasend-to-endsystemcertificationstillneedstobeconductedforbothorganisationstomaximisecomplementarity.

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

7

?OpenlabsslowlypickuptheOpenRANcertificationframeworks.Whilemoreandmorelabsaroundtheglobeopentheirdoors,onlyfewhaveexecutedcertificationtestsonO-RANALLIANCEspecs.NosilverorgoldbadgeshaveyetbeenissuedbasedonTIPblueprints.Moreover,amethodologytogaintrustbetweenlabsandoperatorsstillneedstobeimplemented.Inatrustfulenvironment,operatorscouldacknowledgecertificatestoreducecumbersomeretestingeveniftheywereissuedbyalabtheoperatorsrarelydealwith.

?Requirementsandvalidationprocedurestotestagainstneedtobegloballyorganisedinatransparentandmaintainableway.In2021,theOpenRANMoUgroupinitiatedatechnicalprioritiesworkstreamtopreparealistofimportantRANrequirements,andissuedasecondreleasein2022.ThissetofrequirementsisintendedtoactasvaluableinputintoTIP’sOpenRANReleaseFramework,whichcouldthenbeusedasthebasisofthecertificatesthatoperatorsneed.

Afteraselectionprocess,thoserequirementscanformasetofrequirementsasglobalbasisforcertificates.Validationproceduresshouldbeopensourcedandtestresultsmadeavailabletooperators.

?Thebestworksplitbetweenopenandoperatorlabswillevolveovertime.AhighlyefficientOpenRANvalidationecosystemcouldprocessthebulkofrequiredtestsinopenlabsandreduceoperatorteststocustomrequirements.Bydifferentiatingbetweenglobalbaseandregionalspecificrequirements,theneedsofdifferentgeographicalareascanbeconsideredinopenlabtesting.Commonentry/exitcriteriashouldbedefinedtodriveacleartransferprocessbetweenvendor,openandoperatorlabs.

?Aprocessforlifecyclemanagementofcertificatesisrequiredtoenableupdatestoexistingcertificationrequirements

whiletechnologyadvances.Itcreatesthe

operationalheartbeataroundcertification

andenableslessadvancedvendorstocertify

againstolderversionsofrequirementsif

needed.

?Vendor-specificcertificationapproaches

arecurrentlyevolvingtofilltheexistinggap

foraglobalcertificationsystem.Forthe

sakeofhighestefficiency,thoseproprietary

certificationsystemsshouldideallyendupin

theglobalcertificationframeworksofrelevant

organisationsassoonasthosearemature.

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

1.Technicalandecosystemmaturityandreadiness

8

2.Security

OpenRANMoUOperatorsaremakingsignificantprogresstowardsmoresecureOpenRANdeploymentsbyimplementingrecommendationspublishedbytheNISCooperationGroupinMay2022.

Message1

Collaborationwithnationalauthorities

OpenRANMoUOperatorsarestrengtheningcooperationwithrelevantnationalauthoritiestoshareinformationonthesecurity,implementationandmanagementofOpenRANnetworks.OpenRANMoUOperatorsalreadycollaboratewithnationalauthoritiesincountriessuchastheUK,GermanyandItalybyprovidinginformationontheprogressmadeinsecurityspecificationandtestingaswellasondeploymentplans,whererelevant.

1

Rationale/explanation

?OpenRANMoUOperatorsarestrengtheningcollaborationwithnationalauthoritiestoensuresecuritybaselinerequirementsaremetandthattheriskprofileofvendorsarecorrectlycapturedandassessed(ECNISSM01-SM02).

?OpenRANMoUOperatorsarealsocollaboratingwithindustrybodiessuchasGSMAandO-RANALLIANCEtoprovideOpenRANsecuritytestingspecifications.Thesespecificationsfrominitialdeploymentsaretobetakenasinputforthedefinitionofastandardtestingspecification(ECNISSA01-SA02-SA06).

?OpenRANMoUOperatorscommittocarryingoutsecurityhardeningtesting,consideringbutnotlimitedtoO-RANALLIANCERelease3andanyfuturesecurityassuranceschemerequirementssuchasNESASor5Gcertificationschemethatwillincorporate

OpenRAN.O-RANSecurityTestSpecification

3.0providestestspecificationsforcommonnetworksecuritytests,workprotocolfuzzingguideline,softwarecompositionanalysis,SoftwareBillofMaterials(SBOM)verification,OpenFronthaulPoint-to-PointLANSegmentsecurityverificationbasedon802.1xport-basednetworkaccesscontrol,andO1interfaceNetworkConfigurationAccessControl(NACM)verification.Vendorsandoperatorscanusetheseteststoassessthesecurityoftheirproductsanddeployments.

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

2.Security

9

Message2

Introductionofasecuritycontrols

OpenRANMoUOperatorsarecommittedtostrongsecuritycontrolsthroughoutthelifecycleofOpenRAN.Thisincludes:specification,development,procurement,systemintegration,testingandoperations.Asaminimum,MoUOperatorswillapplyallthemandatorycontrolsdefinedbytheO-RANALLIANCEand3GPPsecurityspecifications.MoUOperatorswillalsorequirethesamesecuritycontrolstobeenforcedacrossOpenRANsupplychains.

2

Rationale/explanation

?TheintroductionofOpenRANwillnotbeanexceptiontoanymandatorycybersecuritypolicyrequirementssuchascontrolsthatpreventunauthorisedaccesstothenetwork(ECNISTM03).Toreinforcethesoftwareintegrity,aswellasupdateandpatchmanagement(ECNISTM07),OpenRANMoUOperatorswillconsiderCI/CT/CD(continuousintegration,continuoustestingandcontinuousdeployment)toolsfrommultiplevendors.RequirementsinthisareawillberequestedaspartofongoingRFI/RFQ(requestforinformation/requestforquotes)activitiesonCT/CDsolutions.

?Moreover,OpenRANMoUOperatorswillensuresupplierscommittoenforcingindustryrecognisedsecurityassurancestandardsinthesoftwaredevelopmentphase.ThiswillhelptodetectpotentialthreatsbymalicioususersespeciallyonOpenFronthaulinterfaceandrApps/xApps.Automationisalsorequiredforperiodicvulnerabilityscanning.

?Inadditiontoautomatedtesting,manualpenetrationtestingactivitieswillbeconducted,especiallywhennewcomponentsandsuppliersareintroduced.

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

2.Security

10

Message3

Supplierassurance

OpenRANMoUOperatorscommitthattheirfutureOpenRANprocurementsandRFQswillensuremandatorycompliancebyOpenRANsuppliers(productsandindividualcomponents)withsecurityspecifications.Asaminimum,thiswouldinclude,forexample,O-RANALLIANCEspecifications,aswellasoperatorsecuritypoliciesandanyrequirementsfromnationalauthorities.

OpenRANMoUOperatorsalreadyfollowaZeroTrustapproachtowardseveryvendor.Furthermore,infuturetheriskprofileofsuppliers(andthirdparties)willincludeanassessmentagainstthecriteriaintheEUCoordinatedRiskAssessment.

3

Rationale/explanation

?AnyOpenRANsuppliersthatparticipateinindividualMoUoperatorprocurementandRFQprocesseswillberequired,asaminimum,tocomplywithindustryestablishedstandardsandspecificationssuchas3GPPandO-RANALLIANCE,aswellasanyrequirementsfromnationalauthoritiesandoperatorsecuritypolicies.

?Furthermore,ManagedServiceProviders(MSPs)willbeevaluatedinthesamewayasequipmentsuppliers(ECNISSM04).MSPandthird-partyvendorswillberequiredtocomplywithmandatoryoperatorsecuritycontrols,aswellasnew5Gcertificationschemes(ENISA),GSMANESASandindustrybadgese.g.TIP.

Message4

Certification

OpenRANsolutionsmustbeassecureastraditionalRANandshouldbesubjecttothesameofficialsecurityassuranceandcertificationprocesses.OpenRANMoUOperatorshavethereforerequestedthatOpenRANshouldbepartofboththe5GcertificationschemebeingdefinedbyENISAandthenextreleaseoftheGSMANESASsecurityassurancescheme.Furthermore,throughtheirparticipationinotherindustryfora(e.g.TIP/O-RANALLIANCE),OpenRANMoUOperatorswillworktosupporttheinclusionofsecurityfeaturesinanycertificationschemes.

4

Rationale/explanation

?Fromanearlystage,thereisanopportunitytointroduceOpenRANaspartoftheENISA5GcertificationschemeandGSMANESAS.TheseschemesarecurrentlyunderdefinitionsothatallfutureOpenRANequipmenthasthesamelevelofsecurityassuranceandcertificationastheconventional5Gequipment(ECNISTM09-10andSM01).OpenRANMoUOperatorsalsocommitto

collaboratewiththenationalauthoritiesonO-RANcloudimplementation(ECNISTM10).

?Furthermore,OpenRANMoUOperatorswillcontinuetocollaborate,sharingbest

practices,lookingtopublishthesewherehelpful,anddefiningadditionalrequirementsforpotentialinclusionbystandardandcertificationbodies(ECNISSA01).

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

2.Security

11

Message5

Securebydesign

OpenRANMoUOperatorsareaddressingoutstandinggapsinsecurityspecificationsthroughtheO-RANALLIANCE.Forexample,WorkingGroup11hasintroducednewsecuritycontrolmechanismsonA1(OAuth2.0)andO2(mTLS)interfacesdefinedinrelease3.0specifications.ThesewerecompletedinNovember2022andwillbepublishedinFebruary2023.OpenRANMoUoperatorshavealsocreatedaparallelSecurityWorkingGroupthatiscreatingacomprehensivesetofsecurityrequirementsaspartoftheOpenRANMoUTechnicalPrioritiesworkstream.

5

Rationale/explanation

?PleaserefertoAnnex1onsecurityspecificationsprogress.

Message6

Vendordiversityandcollaboration

withEuropeansuppliers

OpenRANMoUOperatorsre-iteratetheircommitmenttocollaboratewithawiderangeofsuppliers,includingEuropeanincumbentsuppliersandSMEs,toensureamulti-vendorstrategy.

6

Rationale/explanation

?DiversitywillincreaseresilienceandhelpdevelopaEuropeanecosystemthatwillacceleratecommercialreadiness,increasecompetitionanddriveinnovation.OpenRANMoUOperatorswillconsiderfuturefundingopportunitiessuchastheSNSPartnershipProjectforlarge-scaletrialsbyconsortiumsofEuropeanplayers.

?OpenRANMoUOperatorsareindependentlyassessingawiderangeofsupplierstopotentiallysupplytheelementsofeverylayerinthestack,strengtheningthecollaborationwithEuropeanvendors(ECNISSM03,SM05).Tofosterdiversityandcollaboration,theOpenRANMoUOperatorsencourageconsiderationofbothnewaswellasincumbentsuppliers(ECNISSM08).

12

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

3.Energyefficiency

3.Energyefficiency

EnergyefficiencyofOpenRANsystemsismakingprogress,withtheavailabilityofenergy-efficienthardwarecombinedwithmechanismstoactivatesleepmodesonbothradiotransmittersandcloudinfrastructure.WhiletheinitialtargetistoatleastmatchtheenergyefficiencyoftraditionalRANsolutions,OpenRANwilleventuallybemoreenergyefficientthankstointelligence,withreal-timemonitoring,automatedswitch-on/off,adaptationtotraffic,andnativeAI/ML(artificialintelligence/machinelearning).

Message1

ProgressisbeingmadeintheindustrytoincreasetheenergyefficiencyofallOpenRANbuildingblocks,withparticularfocusonradiotransmittersandcloudinfrastructure.

1

Rationale/explanation

Forradiotransmitters:

?O-RUscontributethegreatestpartofthetotalpowerconsumptionoftheRadioAccessNetwork(around80%),soitisessentialthatOpenRANO-RUsareatleastasenergyefficientasintraditionalRAN.

?ItisworthmentioningthattraditionalO-RUsshowawiderangeofenergy-efficiencyperformancebetweensuppliers(upto25-30%).

?Currently,OpenRANO-RUs’energyefficiencyalreadyfallswithinthetypicalrangeseenwithtraditionalRAN,andtheyshouldfurtherimproveandreachbest-in-classperformance.

?Furthermore,enhancementsarebeingconsideredintheO-RANALLIANCEtoreplicatethesleepmodefeaturesavailablewithtraditionalvendors,allowingcontroloftheO-RUshutdownmodesbytheO-DUthroughtheOpenFronthaulinterface.SeveralfeaturesarebeingconsideredforspecificationintheO-RANALLIANCE(e.g.,shutdownwithdifferentgranularity:symbol,channel,andcarrier).

?OpenRANMoUOperatorshavedefinedenergy-efficiencytargetsforO-RUinbothloadedandunloadedconditions,aspartoftheirtechnicalprioritiescontributiontoTIP’songoingReleaseFramework,theoutputofwhichmaybeusedforbenchmarkingwithtraditionalRAN.

OpenRANMoUprogressupdateonmaturity,securityandenergyefficiency

3.Energyefficiency

13

Forcloudinfrastructure:

?Thebaselineenergyefficiencyofcloudinfrastructureisimprovingintheindustry,thankstoprogressintheefficiencyofCPU(centralprocessingunit)andacceleratortechnologies,butalsocoolingsystemsfor

servers.

?Recentprogresshasbeenmadethankstothelatestevolutionofchipsetandacceleratortechnologies,withtheintroductionofin-lineacceleratorsandmoreintegratedchipsetsnativelyoptimisedforlowerpowerconsumption.

?Progressisalsobeingmad