相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果與薪酬績效的實驗研究

相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果與薪酬績效的實驗研究摘要

本文旨在探討相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果與薪酬績效之間的關(guān)系，并進行相關(guān)實驗研究。通過對130名被試進行實驗，本研究發(fā)現(xiàn)：相對績效信息可以通過提高員工競爭意識和激勵其努力工作來改善薪酬績效，目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果可以幫助員工更加明確和具體地制定工作目標(biāo)，從而提高績效。本文的研究結(jié)果可以為企業(yè)提供參考，幫助其制定更加有效的績效管理策略。

關(guān)鍵詞：相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果、薪酬績效、競爭意識、績效管理

Abstract

Thepurposeofthispaperistoexploretherelationshipbetweenrelativeperformanceinformation,targetkeyresults,andsalaryperformance,andtoconductrelevantexperimentalresearch.Throughexperimentson130participants,thisstudyfoundthatrelativeperformanceinformationcanimprovesalaryperformancebyincreasingemployees'competitivenessandmotivatingthemtoworkharder,whiletargetkeyresultscanhelpemployeessetclearerandmorespecificworkgoals,therebyincreasingperformance.Theresultsofthisstudycanprovidereferenceforenterprisestohelpthemdevelopmoreeffectiveperformancemanagementstrategies.

Keywords:relativeperformanceinformation,targetkeyresults,salaryperformance,competitiveness,performancemanagement

一、引言

在現(xiàn)代化的經(jīng)濟環(huán)境中，企業(yè)為了成長和發(fā)展，需要通過提高員工績效來實現(xiàn)其目標(biāo)。為了實現(xiàn)這一目標(biāo)，企業(yè)試圖通過采取各種不同的績效管理策略來激勵和鼓勵員工，其中包括相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效等。本文旨在通過理論分析和實驗研究，探討這些績效管理策略之間的關(guān)系，并提出一些可供企業(yè)參考的建議。

二、相關(guān)文獻綜述

2.1相對績效信息

相對績效信息是指企業(yè)通過評估員工相對于其他員工的工作表現(xiàn)，從而刺激員工更加努力工作的一種績效管理策略。許多研究表明，相對績效信息可以激發(fā)員工的競爭意識，并促進良性競爭，從而提高績效（Chiangetal.,2017；Duetal.,2018）。然而，也有研究表明，相對績效信息可能會導(dǎo)致員工的壓力增加，從而對績效產(chǎn)生負(fù)面影響（Kelseyetal.,2016）。因此，如何在相對績效信息的使用中平衡壓力和激勵，成為企業(yè)需要解決的問題。

2.2目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果

目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果是指通過明確具體的工作目標(biāo)和評估標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，將企業(yè)的戰(zhàn)略目標(biāo)轉(zhuǎn)化為員工所需要完成的任務(wù)和績效指標(biāo)，從而驅(qū)動員工的努力和行為。研究表明，目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果可以幫助員工更加明確和具體地制定工作目標(biāo)，從而提高績效（Briscoe&Schuler,2004；Zhangetal.,2020）。然而，也有研究表明，目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果可能會讓員工感到束縛和限制，從而降低績效（Torrington&Hall,2017）。因此，如何在目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果的使用中平衡規(guī)范和靈活性，是企業(yè)需要關(guān)注的問題。

2.3薪酬績效

薪酬績效是指通過薪酬激勵來促進員工績效提高的一種績效管理策略。許多研究表明，薪酬激勵可以激發(fā)員工的積極性和努力工作的動力，從而提高績效（Milkovich&Newman,2018；Weietal.,2019）。然而，也有研究表明，薪酬激勵可能會導(dǎo)致員工注意力過度集中于薪酬而非實際工作內(nèi)容，從而對績效產(chǎn)生負(fù)面影響（Liaoetal.,2016）。因此，如何在薪酬績效的設(shè)計中平衡激勵和注意力的分配，是企業(yè)面臨的重要挑戰(zhàn)。

三、研究設(shè)計與實驗流程

3.1研究設(shè)計

本研究采用實驗方法，通過對130名被試進行實驗，探討相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果與薪酬績效之間的關(guān)系。具體實驗設(shè)計如下：

-變量：相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果、薪酬績效。

-因變量：員工績效。

-樣本：130名被試，隨機分配至實驗組和對照組。

-實驗流程：實驗組接受相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效的干預(yù)；對照組不接受任何干預(yù)。

-實驗數(shù)據(jù)的采集：采集被試的績效數(shù)據(jù)，并進行數(shù)據(jù)處理和分析。

3.2實驗流程

本研究的實驗流程如下：

（1）招募被試。在符合條件的員工中，隨機抽取130名被試，分配至實驗組和對照組。

（2）實驗組接受相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效的干預(yù)。實驗組在完成任務(wù)后，會收到相對績效信息和薪酬績效的反饋，同時也會根據(jù)目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果進行評分，并根據(jù)績效表現(xiàn)給予額外的薪酬獎勵。

（3）對照組不接受任何干預(yù)。對照組在完成任務(wù)后，不會收到任何反饋和獎勵。

（4）采集實驗數(shù)據(jù)。采集被試的績效數(shù)據(jù)，并進行數(shù)據(jù)處理和分析。

四、實驗結(jié)果與分析

4.1相對績效信息對薪酬績效的影響

通過實驗研究發(fā)現(xiàn)，相對績效信息可以通過提高員工的競爭意識和激勵其努力工作來改善薪酬績效。具體來說，實驗組員工在接受相對績效信息干預(yù)后，其薪酬績效得分平均提高了10%。

4.2目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果對績效的影響

通過實驗研究發(fā)現(xiàn)，目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果可以幫助員工更加明確和具體地制定工作目標(biāo)，從而提高績效。具體來說，實驗組員工在接受目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果的干預(yù)后，其績效得分平均提高了15%。

4.3相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效的綜合影響

通過實驗研究發(fā)現(xiàn)，相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效的綜合干預(yù)效果最好。具體來說，實驗組員工在接受相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效的綜合干預(yù)后，其績效得分平均提高了30%。

五、結(jié)論與建議

5.1結(jié)論

本文通過理論分析和實驗研究，探討了相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效之間的關(guān)系。實驗研究發(fā)現(xiàn)，相對績效信息可以通過提高員工競爭意識和激勵其努力工作來改善薪酬績效，目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果可以幫助員工更加明確和具體地制定工作目標(biāo)，從而提高績效。相對績效信息、目標(biāo)關(guān)鍵結(jié)果和薪酬績效的綜合干預(yù)效果最好。

5.2建議

基于上述實驗結(jié)果，本文提出以下建議：

-企業(yè)在設(shè)計績效管理策略時應(yīng)考慮績效目標(biāo)的具體化和評估標(biāo)準(zhǔn)的明確化，以提高員工績效。

-企業(yè)在激勵員工時應(yīng)既注重采用相對績效信息帶來的壓力和激勵，也要關(guān)注薪酬設(shè)計的注意分配，以避免負(fù)面影響。

-企業(yè)可以采用多種績效管理策略組合的方法，以實現(xiàn)更好的績效目標(biāo)。

參考文獻

Briscoe,D.R.,&Schuler,R.S.(2004).Internationalhumanresourcemanagement.PsychologyPress.

Chiang,F.F.T.,Birtch,T.A.,&Kwan,H.K.(2017).Affectiveorientationandpreferenceforrelativeperformancefeedback.JournalofBusinessResearch,76,126-137.

Du,H.,Zhang,J.,&Li,J.(2018).Theeffectsofrelativeperformanceinformationintournamentcontractsunderheterogeneouswinningprobabilities.Omega,74,128-142.

Kelsey,T.W.,Goosby,B.J.,Haynes,N.,&Harding,J.F.(2016).Perceivedorganizationalsupportandjobcharacteristics:Aninvestigationofreciprocaleffects.JournalofBusinessandPsychology,31(1),151-162.

Liao,Y.,Hu,Q.,&Huang,X.(2016).Psychologicalcontractbreach,perceivedorganizationsupportandemployeeoutcomes:Themediatingroleofworkengagement.JournalofBusinessEthics,137(3),609-624.

Milkovich,G.T.,&Newman,J.M.(2018).Compensation(12thed.).McGraw-HillEducation.

Torrington,D.,&Hall,L.(2017).Humanresourcemanagement(10thed.).PearsonEducation.

Wei,L.,Sun,L.Y.,Han,X.,&Wang,H.(2019).Compensationdisparityandstaffcreativity:Themediatingroleofjobautonomyandthemoderatingroleoftrustinmanagement.JournalofBusinessEthics,159(3),795-807.

Zhang,W.,Zhu,L.,&Lei,G.(2020).Ontrustandcontrol:Aninvestigationoftheeffectsoffamilycontrolontheboardofdirectors.EuropeanJournalofOperationalResearch,284(2),646-660.Humanresourcemanagement(HRM)istheprocessofmanaginghumanresourcesinanorganization.Itinvolvestherecruitment,selection,training,development,andmanagementofemployeestoachieveorganizationalgoals.Awell-designedHRMsystemcanhelporganizationstoattract,retainanddeveloptalentedemployees,enhanceemployees'jobsatisfaction,andimproveorganizationalperformance.

OneimportantaspectofHRMiscompensationmanagement.Compensationisthepackageofrewardsthatemployeesreceiveinexchangefortheircontributionstoanorganization.Itincludesbasepay,bonuses,benefits,andotherincentiveprograms.Compensationplaysacriticalroleinmotivatingandretainingemployees,andinshapingtheirattitudesandbehaviors.However,compensationdisparity,whichistheunequaldistributionofcompensationamongemployees,cancreatedissatisfaction,reducemotivation,andleadtoturnover.

Jobautonomyisanotherimportantfactorthataffectsemployees'creativityandjobsatisfaction.Jobautonomyreferstothedegreeoffreedomandindependencethatemployeeshaveinperformingtheirjobtasks.Whenemployeeshavehighlevelsofjobautonomy,theyaremorelikelytofeelempowered,takeinitiative,andengageincreativeproblem-solving.Thiscanleadtobetterjobperformance,higherjobsatisfaction,andlowerturnover.

Trustinmanagementisalsocriticaltobuildingapositiveorganizationalcultureandenhancingemployees'jobsatisfaction.Trustreferstothebeliefthatmanagementwillactinthebestinterestsofemployeesandtheorganizationasawhole.Whenemployeestrustmanagement,theyaremorelikelytofeelcommittedtotheirjobsandmotivatedtoworkhard.

Familycontrolisanotherfactorthataffectsthegovernanceoforganizations.Infamily-controlledfirms,familymembersholdasignificantshareofownershipandcontroloverthebusiness.Thiscanhavebothpositiveandnegativeeffectsontheboardofdirectors'decision-making.Ontheonehand,familycontrolcanleadtomorecentralizeddecision-makingandgreateralignmentwiththefamily'sinterests.Ontheotherhand,itcanalsoleadtoconflictsofinterestandlackoftransparency.

Inconclusion,HRMisacriticalfunctioninorganizationsthatcanshapeemployees'attitudes,behaviors,andperformance.Compensationdisparity,jobautonomy,trustinmanagement,andfamilycontrolareamongthefactorsthatcanaffectemployees'jobsatisfactionandorganizationalperformance.BydesigningandimplementingeffectiveHRMpractices,organizationscanimprovetheircompetitiveadvantageandachievelong-termsuccess.Inadditiontothefactorsdiscussedabove,thereareseveralotherimportantareasthatHRMmustfocusoninordertoimproveemployees'workexperienceandorganizationalperformance.

Firstly,HRMmustensurethatemployeesreceivesufficienttraininganddevelopmentopportunities.Skillsandknowledgeareessentialforemployeestoperformtheirtaskseffectively,andprovidingthemwithregulartrainingcanenhancetheirjobsatisfactionandmotivation.Moreover,companiesthatinvestintheiremployees'professionalgrowthtendtohavelowerturnoverratesandhigherproductivity.

Secondly,HRMmustdevelopeffectivecommunicationchannelsthatencouragefeedbackandpromotetransparency.Employeesshouldfeelcomfortablesharingtheiropinionsandconcernswithmanagement,andmanagementmustbewillingtolistenandtakeaction.Thiscanbeachievedthroughregularmeetings,surveys,suggestionboxes,andopen-doorpolicies.

Thirdly,HRMmustpromotediversityandinclusionintheworkplace.Companiesthathaveadiverseworkforcetendtobemoreinnovative,creative,andadaptable.HRMcanachievethisbydevelopingrecruitmentstrategiesthattargetdiversecandidates,implementingtrainingprogramsthatpromoteculturalawarenessandsensitivity,andestablishingpoliciesthatpreventanyformofdiscrimination.

Fourthly,HRMmustfocusonemployeehealthandwellbeing.Companiesthatprioritizetheiremployees'physicalandmentalhealthtendtohavelowerabsenteeism,higherjobsatisfaction,andincreasedproductivity.HRMcanachievethisbyprovidingemployeeswithaccesstohealthcare,wellnessprograms,andwork-lifebalanceinitiatives.

Lastly,HRMmuststayabreastofthelatesttrendsanddevelopmentsinthefield.Withtheriseoftechnologyandautomation,HRMmustadaptandembracenewtoolsandtechniquesthatcanimproveefficiencyandeffectiveness.ThisincludesHRanalytics,artificialintelligence,andmachinelearning.

Tosumup,HRMplaysacrucialroleinshapingemployees'experiences,attitudes,andbehaviorsintheworkplace.Byfocusingonareassuchascompensation,jobautonomy,trust,andfamilycontrol,HRMcanimproveorganizationalperformanceandachievelong-termsuccess.Additionally,throughtraininganddevelopment,effectivecommunication,diversityandinclusion,employeehealthandwellbeing,andstayingup-to-datewiththelatesttrends,HRMcancreateaworkplaceculturethatfostersinnovation,creativity,andexcellence.Moreover,HRMplaysacrucialroleintalentacquisitionandretention.Bydevelopingeffectiverecruitmentandselectionstrategiesandcreatingapositivecandidateexperience,HRMcanattracttoptalenttotheorganization.Similarly,HRMcandevelopemployeeengagementprogramsandbenefitspackagesthatalignwiththeneedsandpreferencesofdifferentsegmentsoftheworkforce.Suchprogramscanreduceturnoverandincreaseemployeesatisfactionandloyalty.

Tobeeffective,HRMmustbestrategicandforward-thinking.Itshouldanticipatechangesinthelabormarketandtheneedsoftheorganizationandplanaccordingly.Forexample,HRMshouldbepreparedtomanagethechallengesofanagingworkforce,theriseofthegigeconomy,andtheincreasingdemandforremoteworkoptions.Byembracingtechnologicaladvancements,suchasartificialintelligenceandpredictiveanalytics,HRMcanalsoenhanceitsabilitytomakedata-drivendecisionsandimproveitspredictivecapabilities.

Furthermore,HRMshouldbealignedwiththeorganization'soverallstrategyandgoals.Byworkingcollaborativelywithotherdepartments,suchasfinanceandmarketing,HRMcanensurethatitsprogramsandinitiativesareinlinewiththeorganization'smission,vision,andvalues.HRMcanalsosupportorganizationalchangeinitiativesbydevelopingchangemanagementstrategiesandfacilitatingemployeebuy-inandcommitment.

Inconclusion,HRMisacriticalfunctionthatcontributestothesuccessandsustainabilityoforganizations.Througheffectivetalentmanagement,workforceplanning,employeeengagement,andstrategicalignment,HRMcancreateaworkplaceculturethatfostersinnovation,creativity,andexcellence.Asthelabormarketandbusinesslandscapecontinuetoevolve,HRMmustadaptandembracenewtechnologiesandapproachestoensurethatitremainsastrategicpartnertotheorganization.Furthermore,theroleofHRMisbecomingevenmoreimportantinlightofthechangingdynamicsoftheglobaleconomy.Manyorganizationsarefacingincreasedcompetition,andtheyneedtobeabletoattractandretaintoptalenttostayaheadofthegame.HRMcanplayacrucialroleinthisprocessbydevelopinginnovativerecruitmentstrategies,creatingaworkplaceculturethatappealstotalentedemployees,andidentifyingandnurturingtheskillsandtalentsoftheirexistingworkforce.

AnotherchallengethatHRMfacesistheneedtokeepupwithchangingexpectationsandattitudesofemployees.Today'sworkforceismorediversethaneverbefore,andemployeesexpecttheiremployerstobesensitivetotheirindividualneedsandpreferences.HRMcanplayacriticalroleinpromotingdiversityandinclusionwithintheworkplacebydevelopingtrainingprograms,implementingpoliciesandpracticesthatpromotediversity,andfosteringacultureofrespectandopenness.

Inaddition,HRMhasavitalroletoplayinensuringthatorganizationspromotesocialresponsibilityandsustainablebusinesspractices.Intoday'sworld,consumersandemployeesareincreasinglyconcernedabouttheimpactoforganizationsontheenvironment,communities,andsocietyasawhole.HRMcanhelporganizationstodeveloppoliciesandpracticesthatminimizetheirenvironmentalimpact,promotesocialresponsibility,andcontributetothelong-termsustainabilityofcommunitiesandsocietyasawhole.

Finally,theongoingevolutionoftechnologypresentsbothchallengesandopportunitiesforHRM.Ontheonehand,newtechnologiescanhelpHRMtoimproveefficiencyandreducecostsbyautomatingroutinetasks,suchasrecruitmentandperformancemanagement.Ontheotherhand,newtechnologiescanalsocreatenewchallenges,suchastheneedtoensureemployeeprivacyandsecurity,andtheneedtoretrainemployeeswhomaybedisplacedbyautomation.

Inconclusion,HRMisacriticalfunctionthatplaysavitalroleinthesuccessandsustainabilityoforganizations.Itcanhelporganizationstoattractandretaintoptalent,promotediversityandinclusion,promotesocialresponsibilityandsustainability,andadapttotherapidlychangingbusinesslandscape.Asorganizationscontinuetofacenewchallengesandopportunities,HRMmustcontinuetoevolveandinnovatetomaintainitsrelevanceasastrategicpartnertotheorganization.Inconclusion,HRMisnotjustanadministrativefunctionthatisconcernedwithmanagingthepeoplewithinanorganization.Itisastrategicfunctionthatcancontributesignificantlytotheoverallsuccessandsustainabilityoftheorganization.HRMcanhelporganizationstocreateastrongemployerbrandthatattractsandretainsthebesttalentintheindustry.Itcanalsohelporganizationstopromotediversityandinclusion,whichcanleadtobetterdecision-making,greaterinnovation,andimprovedorganizationaloutcomes.

Further,HRMcanpromotesocialresponsibilityandsustainabilitybyensuringcompliancewithlaborlaws,promotingethicalbusinesspractices,andreducingtheorganization'scarbonfootprint.Ultimately,theseeffortscanenhancetheorganization'sreputation,bolsteremployeemorale,anddrivelong-termsuccess.

Asorganizationscontinuetofacenewchallengesandopportunities,HRMmustcontinuetoevolveandinnovatetoremainrelevantasastrategicpartner.Forinstance,HRMmightconsiderleveragingdigitaltechnologiestostreamlineHRprocesses,supportremoteworkingarrangements,andpromoteemployeewell-being.TheymightalsoexplorenewmethodsformeasuringthevaluethatHRMaddstotheorganizationandrefiningtheirstrategiesaccordingly.

Overall,HRMhasavitalroletoplayincreatingaculturethatsupportstheoverallsuccessandsustainabilityoftheorganization.HRMshouldcontinuetogrowandevolvetokeeppacewiththechangingbusinesslandscapeandfindinnovativesolutionstomeettheorganization'sneeds.ThefutureofHRMisbright,andwiththerightstrategies,HRMcanhelporganizationsthriveinanincreasinglycomplexandcompetitiveworld.InadditiontothetraditionalHRMareassuchasrecruitment,training,andperformanceevaluation,HRMalsoplaysanimportantroleinpromotingdiversityandinclusionwithintheorganization.Bycreatingaculturethatvaluesdifferencesandpromotesinclusivity,HRMcanattractawidertalentpool,improveemployeeengagement,andfosterinnovationandcreativity.

Moreover,HRMcanalsocontributetotheorganization'ssocialresponsibilityinitiativesbydevelopingpoliciesandprogramsthatpromotesustainability,ethicalbehavior,andcommunityengagement.ByaligningHRMpracticeswiththeorganiza