IMBA中期論文評分參考標準

1、IMBA中期論文評分參考標準評價要素評估內容分項細分學位論文進展情況針對開題答辯所提問題的修改情況滿分20分修改情況匯報（20分）學位論文進展情況（對照開題報告的研究進度完成情況）滿分20分基本完成論文，有完整的結構；（5分）完成數(shù)據(jù)分析并有基本結論；（10分）論文各部分基本在達到附件論文評價參考標準；（5分）是否能按時完成能否按時按期完成學位論文（有無論文初稿或詳細大綱）滿分15分階段性成果學術論文發(fā)表情況或專業(yè)實踐成果完成情況滿分25分發(fā)表于論文相關的成果或者完成培養(yǎng)計劃要求的實踐環(huán)節(jié)（25分）報告陳述語言表達能力及對論文表述的條理性滿分20分答辯過程思路清晰、對專家提問能進行充分的解釋、

2、對研究領域具有相當?shù)牧私猓?0分）中期考核結果(校指導性文件)評估內容分項打分總分研究綜述（國內外研究現(xiàn)狀報告）滿分20分學位論文進展情況和階段性成果（對照開題報告的研究進度完成情況）滿分20分能否按時按期完成學位論文（有無論文初稿或詳細大綱）滿分15分學術論文發(fā)表情況或專業(yè)實踐成果完成情況滿分25分語言表達能力及對論文表述的條理性滿分20分 A.通過，繼續(xù)攻讀（90-100分） B.小幅修改，繼續(xù)攻讀（70-89分） C.大幅修改后二次檢查（60-69分）2個月后可二次檢查 D.不合格，限期整改（60分以下） 延期半年附件：IMBA論文評價參考標準論文選題/標題選題應來源于企業(yè)管理實踐，對解

3、決實際問題有一定的參考價值標題應簡潔、精煉、準確、通俗易懂地表達論文核心思想論文結構論文結構完整，涵蓋了MBA畢業(yè)論文要求的各個組成部分論文主體部分章節(jié)安排合理，前后邏輯性強文獻綜述文獻綜述的內容應與論文選題和研究內容緊密相關綜述內容應包含相關領域的最新研究進展，引用文獻避免過于陳舊，文獻質量高，包含自己對已有文獻的評述。研究方法研究方法選擇得當，與研究問題和研究內容匹配度好研究方法的運用應準確無誤，無明顯紕漏或失誤論文成果研究成果具有一定的創(chuàng)新性探索了有價值的現(xiàn)實問題，具有較好的應用價值，解決實際問題寫作能力論文各組成部分的撰寫格式符合MBA寫作規(guī)范的要求，包括圖表無割裂、序號層次分明、各級

4、標題設置正確、引文規(guī)范等行文流暢、邏輯通順、條理清晰；充分運用圖表來輔助表達，數(shù)據(jù)詳實、論證充分；參考文獻近5年的期刊參考文獻占1/2以上；80%以上為SSCI/SCI檢索；5篇以上參考文獻需發(fā)表在影響因子2.0以上的期刊。參考文獻體例規(guī)范；所列參考文獻必須是論文中實際引用的文獻；IMBA Mid-term Dissertation Defense Evaluation CriteriaComponentContentMarkingDissertation ProgressResponse to Questions raised in topic defense20 MarksReport a

5、ll answers to Questions and argue using existing literatures (20 marks)Report the current progress according to the topic defense proposal20 MarksDraft 90% finished with complete structure (5 marks)Data analysis completed and results discussed (10 marks)All parts satisfy evaluation criteria outlined

6、 in appendix below (5 marks)Completion LikelihoodHow likely the thesis will be completed on time15 MarksAchievementArticle publication or Practical Activity Report25 MarksArticle published or have attended business practical activities with report completed (25 marks)PresentationClearly and Logicall

7、y explain Questions raised by panelists 20 MarksRespond to all questions with clear logic and rigor and has sufficient understanding of he/her own research field (20 marks) A. Pass（90-100 marks） B. Minor Revision（70-89 marks） C. Major Revision（60-69 marks）Re-defense in 2 month D. Fail（Less than 60 m

8、arks） Graduation Postponed to another 6 months Appendix：IMBA Dissertation Evaluation CriteriaTopic Selection and titleTopic is related to MBATitle is accurate, succinct and easy to understand to convey the core message of the dissertationTopic is of good theoretical and practical significanceStructu

9、reStructure is complete, involving all required chapters of MBA thesisThe order of chapters is logical and reasonableLiterature reviewLiteratures being reviewed should closely related to the keywords and titleMajority of literatures being reviewed should be recent You should criticize some recent li

10、teratures using your own opinions and highlight what your current dissertation could do to overcome problems in existing literatures MethodMethod is appropriate, and in line with research method and contentStatistical analysis is operated rigorously and accurately Results and discussionThe results s

11、hould be discussed. That is, why hypotheses are accepted? Why some are rejected? (using your own words and literatures to support it)Results should be innovativeResults should have good managerial implications to solve current problems in practiceWritingLogical and sufficient reasoning,Satisfy format requirement of MBA thesis；Adopt sufficient figures and tables to support findingsReferencesHalf of references need to be from articles published in the recent 5 years; at least 80% of references need to be SSCI/SCI indexed; Referen